What is the difference between opal and boulder opal?

Boulder Opals: Earth's Natural Doublets

Why these geological marvels deserve a place in your jewelry collection

These stones are some of nature's most ingenious creations—and once you understand what makes them special, you'll never look at them the same way.

14k Opal Doublet Studs - Mettle by Abby
Above: Opal Doublet Studs

Boulder Opal vs. Regular Opal: What's the Difference?

Before diving into boulder opals specifically, let's clear up the confusion. Regular opals—like the crystal opals, white opals, or black opals you might know—are pure opal material that formed in cavities or seams in the earth. They're solid opal all the way through (or mostly through, in the case of opal on potch - what opal is formed on).

Boulder opals are completely different animals. They're opals that formed within the cracks and fissures of host rock—usually ironstone in Australia or rhyolite in Mexico. The opal didn't replace the rock; instead, it filled the spaces and became permanently bonded to it during formation.

14k Opal Star Dust Ring - Mettle by Abby
Above: White Australian Opal 

What Makes Boulder Opals Extraordinary

Picture this: millions of years ago, silica-rich water seeped into cracks and crevices of ironstone rock. As the water evaporated, it left behind layers of precious opal, creating what I call "Earth's natural doublets." Unlike the man-made doublets you see in jewelry stores—where opal is artificially glued to a backing—boulder opals formed this way naturally, with the host rock becoming an integral part of the stone's beauty.

Think of it this way: if regular opal is like a standalone painting, boulder opal is like a painting that includes its frame as part of the artwork. You can't separate the opal from the rock without destroying the stone entirely—they're geologically married.

Boulder Opal Statement Necklace - Mettle by Abby
Above: Australian Boulder Opal

The Australian Legends

Australian boulder opals are the rockstars of this family. The host rock typically shows up as rich, chocolate-brown ironstone (which often seems almost metallic), while the opal blazes across the surface in electric blues, purples, and greens. The contrast is dramatic—like lightning against a stormy sky, or atmospheric like pockets of blooming opal amidst rock.

What fascinates me most about Australian boulders is how the opal seems to float on the surface of the rock. Sometimes you'll find veins of fire dancing through the brown matrix, creating patterns that look almost like abstract paintings. Each stone tells a story of ancient geological forces, and no two are ever alike.

The quality ranges from subtle whispers of color to full-blown symphonies of light. The finest pieces can rival black opals in their intensity, but with the added drama of that earthy backdrop.

Above: One of the prettiest Mexican Boulder Opals

The Mexican Treasures

Then there are the Mexican boulder opals—a completely different personality altogether. Where Australian stones are moody and dramatic, Mexican boulders are warm and inviting. The host rock appears in creamy whites and soft beiges, while the opal portion glows in peachy pinks, sunset oranges, and honey golds.

14k Rose Gold Star Dust Mexican Boulder Opal Ring - Mettle by Abby
Above: Mexican Boulder Opal

I've had the privilege of hand-selecting Mexican boulder opals at the Tucson Gem Show multiple times, and each trip teaches me something new. The Mexican varieties often absorbs oils and can change color over time. There's something about the way the opal formed in the Mexican rhyolite that creates a more unified structure.

Why Boulder Opals Make Exceptional Jewelry

From a goldsmith's perspective, boulder opals are a dream to work with. The rock backing provides natural stability—you don't need to baby them the way you might with crystal opals. They can handle everyday wear better than most opal varieties.

The design possibilities are endless. Sometimes I'll embrace the natural shape, creating organic, flowing settings that complement the stone's earthy origins. Other times, I'll use geometric shapes that highlight the interplay between the opal and rock portions.

The color combinations are particularly striking in settings. Australian boulder opals look incredible in oxidized silver or warm gold, while Mexican varieties practically glow when set in rose gold and silver.

Caring for Your Boulder Opal

Boulder opals are relatively low-maintenance, but they do appreciate some consideration:

  • Avoid sudden temperature changes - Like all opals, they contain water and can be sensitive to extreme heat or cold
  • Clean gently - Warm soapy water and a soft cloth are all you need
  • Store carefully - While more stable than crystal opals, they can still chip if knocked against other stones
14k Rose Gold Boulder Opal Ring - Mettle by Abby
Above: Mexican Boulder Opal

The Boulder Opal Investment

These stones represent excellent value in the opal world. You get the beauty and play-of-color that makes opals so captivating, plus the added interest of the natural rock matrix, often at a fraction of the cost of comparable black opals.

For collectors, boulder opals offer something unique: each piece is a complete geological specimen, not just a gemstone. You're not just wearing jewelry—you're wearing a piece of Earth's ancient history.

14k White Gold Boulder Opal Halo Necklace - Mettle by Abby
Above: Australian Boulder Opal

Finding Your Perfect Boulder Opal

When selecting a boulder opal, look for:

  • Strong play-of-color that shifts as you move the stone
  • Good contrast between the opal and host rock
  • Stable appearance with no obvious cracks or separations
  • Pleasing proportions between the opal and rock portions

The best boulder opals have opal that seems to dance across the surface, creating patterns that draw your eye deeper into the stone.


Boulder opals represent everything I love about working with gemstones—they're beautiful, unique, and tell a story that spans geological ages. Whether you choose the dramatic intensity of Australian stones or the warm glow of Mexican varieties, you're choosing a piece of jewelry that's as individual as you are.

Ready to explore boulder opals for your collection? Each stone I work with is hand-selected for its exceptional beauty and stability—because you deserve jewelry that's as extraordinary as the stories it tells.

Back to blog

Shop the newest Mettle earrings

1 of 13